Guidelines for the Peer Reviewers
JSWEP is following double blind peer review process to ensure the quality of the articles published. To help guide our peer reviewers we recommend the following ten questions to consider during the review process.
1. Evaluate the Strength or Weakness of the paper
2. Is the submission original?
3. Does it help to expand or further research in this subject area?
4. Does the paper fit the scope of the journal?
5. Would you recommend that the author reconsider the paper for a related or alternative journal?
6. Should it be shortened and reconsidered in another form?
7. Would the paper be of interest to the readership of the journal?
8. Is there an abstract as well as conclusion and reference/bibliography sections?
9. Is the submission in English? Is it understandable to the reader?
10. Is the Methodology and Analysis provided are accurate?
In addition to that we recommend you to follow the instructions given below:
Confidentiality
Manuscripts sent to you are confidential documents. Please do not discuss it even with a colleague. If you think someone else can contribute to the peer review process of the manuscript you received, provide the email of that person. editorjswep@gmail.com.
Time limit
You have to submit the review within seven (7) days from the date you receive it. If you want more time, you may ask for it by email to editorjswep@gmail.com. An extension of the period will be considered and informed by the editor (only up to three (3) days).
Writing the report
You have to send the report to the editor by email editorjswep@gmail.com. You can write the report in the body of your email or attach a word/pdf report to the email.
Writing recommendation
As part of your report you have to clearly state what your recommendation is (Accept/Minor Revision/Major Revision/Reject) and also provide the title of the manuscript in the report.
If you need any more clarification please write to us by email editorjswep@gmail.com
JSWEP is following double blind peer review process to ensure the quality of the articles published. To help guide our peer reviewers we recommend the following ten questions to consider during the review process.
1. Evaluate the Strength or Weakness of the paper
2. Is the submission original?
3. Does it help to expand or further research in this subject area?
4. Does the paper fit the scope of the journal?
5. Would you recommend that the author reconsider the paper for a related or alternative journal?
6. Should it be shortened and reconsidered in another form?
7. Would the paper be of interest to the readership of the journal?
8. Is there an abstract as well as conclusion and reference/bibliography sections?
9. Is the submission in English? Is it understandable to the reader?
10. Is the Methodology and Analysis provided are accurate?
In addition to that we recommend you to follow the instructions given below:
Confidentiality
Manuscripts sent to you are confidential documents. Please do not discuss it even with a colleague. If you think someone else can contribute to the peer review process of the manuscript you received, provide the email of that person. editorjswep@gmail.com.
Time limit
You have to submit the review within seven (7) days from the date you receive it. If you want more time, you may ask for it by email to editorjswep@gmail.com. An extension of the period will be considered and informed by the editor (only up to three (3) days).
Writing the report
You have to send the report to the editor by email editorjswep@gmail.com. You can write the report in the body of your email or attach a word/pdf report to the email.
Writing recommendation
As part of your report you have to clearly state what your recommendation is (Accept/Minor Revision/Major Revision/Reject) and also provide the title of the manuscript in the report.
If you need any more clarification please write to us by email editorjswep@gmail.com
